The Defensive Dilemma – Options Available as Bolger Sits Portsmouth Game Out

Neal Eardley, Callum Connolly, Jason Shackell, Harry Toffolo


Courtesy Graham Burrell

I almost feel like I have to write ‘the much-maligned’ before Callum’s name because for a short period he became the scapegoat some of our supporters love to have. Admittedly, he didn’t have a great game against Oxford but there’s a bit of the ‘Tom Champion’ here; he came in at a time when a natural dip occurred and his arrival was believed to be the problem. It wasn’t.

I don’t think there’s scope in the middle of the park for him; Joe Morrell and Michael O’Connor is the natural pairing there, combining experience and endeavour, youth and flair. That leaves the Under 20 World Cup winner looking for an ‘in’ elsewhere and centre back is likely to be it. My gut feeling is this is the choice Michael Appleton will make.

Over the course of his career, Connolly has played centre back and this is one reason I feel we’ll go with him in there. He played there for Wigan a few times in his spells with the Latics and for Everton Under 21s as well. In terms of a natural replacement, he’s perhaps the closest we have. He’s a good height too and his younger legs will give us something that we haven’t had in the middle for a while; some pace.

In his games as a central defender, he’s won 78% of his defensive duels, 62% of his aerial duels and made seven clearances a game on average. He’s featured there against Leeds United, Derby County, Stoke City, Aston Villa and Newcastle United which suggests he is a credible and likely starter tomorrow night.



  1. Hate to be a pedant but there’s a typo in your headline ‘availabe’ (also in the URL). I’m sure you’d like to change it :).

  2. I hope I dont see Tyler Walker on the left again, if Akinde comes on again I would like to see him take up Paynes postion. Walker must keep that central position.

  3. This was the danger. Cowley had built a dangerously unbalanced squad. If Shackel, and ageing centre back, picks up an injury we really are struggling. Or if he picks up a card as he has form for.

  4. Fully agree with Malcolm. Walker needs to stay central as he is our only one goal scoring striker. That was an odd change last Friday…
    As for tomorrow I would play 3 centre backs with Melbourne and Eards around Shackell and Lewis/Toff as a wing backs…
    Little bit worried about tomorrow’s aerial battles in our box if am honest.. We all know how good Ragget is in this aspect….

2 Trackbacks / Pingbacks

  1. You don’t always get what you deserve: Portsmouth 1-0 Imps – The Stacey West
  2. Big Defensive Decision Awaits Michael Appleton This Weekend – The Stacey West

Comments are closed.