The Stacey West’s Five Most Unpopular Lincoln City Opinions

Okay, they might not be the most unpopular Lincoln City opinions, but they are ones I think a few will debate.

Over my 40-odd years as a Lincoln City fan, I’ve had a lot of opinions, as many of you have as well. Some are mainstream: Keith Alexander was a legend; we should have gone up in 2004/05; Kevin Hulme was a bad signing. These are hardly groundbreaking, are they? They’re as close to established fact without actually being facts.

There are some opinions which buck the trend, which go against the grain and will produce a shaken head and a chuckle. I’ve got five of them (I’ve got a lot more, but these five will do for now) to see if you agree or disagree. They’re not in any particular order either, so enjoy (or don’t) and let me know what you think. Politely.

George Kerr Would Have Kept Us Up In 1987

I was accused the other week of being too fair on George Kerr, and this was my first season, so I’m not sure my opinion as an eight-year-old carried much weight, but looking back, I do think George Kerr could have prevented our slide into the GMVC. Where we’d be now, I don’t know, because Murphy’s return and the GMVC win set us up for a decade or so, but remember, we were a Third Division team in many people’s eyes, and we passed through the fourth like a dodgy prawn curry.

Here’s a fact. Kerr was sacked on March 9th, 1987. At the time, we were 17th, 14 points clear of the bottom spot with 14 matches left to play. He was sacked after a run of just seven points from 12 matches. That’s not a great record.

However, in those 12 matches, we played seven teams in the top 13 at the end of the season. Of the five we played in the bottom half, we beat Burnley 2-1, Halifax 2-1, and drew with Stockport, and lost to Tranmere. So, we actually took seven points from four games against teams around us. He lost 2-1 in his final game against Peterborough, but City led, and only individual errors cost Kerr.

After he left, we faced Rochdale, Hartlepool, Torquay, Exeter, Hereford, Halifax and Stockport, six of the seven teams directly below us, and the one above us, whom we had a game in hand over. We took seven points from those games, arguably a worse return than before. Leading scorer Gary Lund didn’t score again and was dropped for the crucial trip to Stockport on April 20th, while Peter Daniel’s new signings, Derek Hood, Glenn Humphries and Jimmy Gilligan failed to meaningfully contribute.

George Kerr might not have been the man for the long-term job, but we’d never have played away at Fisher Athletic if he’d stayed.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply