
The Ugly: Jack Payne
I called Jack Payne a Rolls Royce of a player when we signed him in July 2019, and a few Southend fans were happy to tell me I’d got carried away. I could see why Danny Cowley wanted him. He’d been Southend’s Player of the Year, scored a winner at Newcastle United for Huddersfield Town and hit nine league goals on loan at Bradford City the previous season. I thought he was exactly the sort of player who could give us an edge in our first season back in League One.
Payne was a regular under Cowley and scored our first goal under Michael Appleton in a 2-1 defeat at Blackpool. As the season wore on, Appleton increasingly turned to Jake Hesketh in the No. 10 role, a decision that had me scratching my head then and still does now. Payne finished with two goals in 30 appearances in all competitions and left for Swindon Town the following summer.
He scored 17 goals in 78 league games at Swindon, made 42 league appearances for Charlton and had a season on loan at Milton Keynes Dons before reuniting with Danny and Nicky Cowley at Colchester United. His first season there put him in the League Two Team of the Season and the PFA League Two Team of the Year. That’s what makes this one ugly for me. We had a player who could have been a big player for us, and we only ever saw glimpses of what he’d done before and went on to do elsewhere.
Leave a Reply