
Speaking to Tom afterwards, I got the impression that he’s tired of doing press conferences by the time he gets to us, and also that there’s a slight exasperation there, because we had some good moments. Wickens played a big ball over the top for House, who got himself into a great position but couldn’t finish. Street had to loft a ball, admittedly on the bounce, over seven players and under the bar, but couldn’t hit the net. We had moments, more than Wrexham in terms of shots, better than Wrexham in terms of xG. Still lost.
That brings me to the question of quality, which I’m not going to avoid. I’m not going to annihilate the performance, but I am going to question the quality, and it’s been a question mark over this team for a long while now. You only have to look at Wrexham’s number 12, Issa Kaboré, to see the difference, because he gets on the ball and wants to beat players. Yes, I know those players cost money, but we’re going to need some of them, and it’s as simple as that.
When we wanted to change the game, we brought on Reeco Hackett, who is a good, honest professional but can’t consistently beat a player, and Chiedozie Ogbene, who was meant to be exactly that player and was meant to be doing what Kaboré did in the early part of the game, but hasn’t. We started with Wheatley, who was anonymous (let’s be honest) and we just don’t have the quality.
At one point in the second half, a long ball came to Street and all he had to do was take a touch and try to beat his man, but he brought it down, went backwards and we reset. I won’t call the person out, but I sit on a row with esteemed Lincoln City figures who have watched decades of football and one you’ll know summed it up. ‘Nobody wants to just beat a man and have a go’. I’m not sure if it is want, or ability.

That would be fine if the long balls and crosses into the box were creating something, but that was what we were good at last season, when we’d create something, get bodies in and find a toe on it, and this season we aren’t. House is a Championship player when it comes to work rate, but when it comes to technique, he isn’t, and that’s just fact. You have to have him in the team, he was excellent again, but you have to pair that work rate with technique somewhere in the team, and we don’t have enough of it. I’m not calling out Street on his own, it looks like it, but I’m not. He looks like a League One player doing his best, Hackett looks like a League One player doing his best, and Bayliss, who is already coming in for quite a bit of stick and gave the ball away at times, looks like a League One player doing his best too.
There’s a theme emerging, and it’s not one I enjoy identifying. These are good guys, good professionals, but the shout here is: if you start in the Championship with Tom Bayliss over Yunus Konak, and Rob Street over Chio Ogbene or Tanto Olafoe (however good or bad they’ve been), you have to back that up with a win. We did at Preston; we didn’t yesterday.
There were some really good deliveries into the box against Wrexham, despite the criticism I’ve heard that we aren’t beating the first man, but we weren’t doing anything with them. Tom spoke after the game about needing more optimism in the box, and I understand what he means, because the ball was bouncing around the penalty spot and the six-yard box and nobody was sniffing it out. Set pieces were our superpower last season, and with Michael Skubala and Scott Fry gone, we’re often told that what we’re doing on set pieces is brilliant, but it isn’t. We’re not creating the havoc we were creating even earlier in the season, when Derby and Middlesbrough didn’t know how to defend against our long throws and corners, and now it looks as if we don’t really know what to do with them ourselves. We’re just putting a ball in there and hoping.

Which brings me to the corner at the end of the game. When you’ve got Mikkel Ladefoged on the pitch, and you’re Lincoln City, one of whose strengths is putting the ball into the box and getting monsters into the area, playing a corner straight to the front post, head height, is criminal. That should be a week’s wage fine for me. I’d go as far as to say it was more unforgivable than Daniel Oyegoke’s mistake, because at least with that mistake there was a genuine intent to do something.
That mistake is the thing that cost us. Oyegoke was played into trouble by Deji Elerewe, so let’s not put it all on one person. Oyegoke had a good game aside from that moment, so I’m not calling him out. Oyegoke has played in Serie A, and earlier in the season there was talk of Elerewe being a five, six or seven million pound defender, and I stick by that. But between them, they contributed to handing over that goal, and that has to improve. I did like that as Oyegoke sank to his knees, gutted, Bradley was straight over to him. He’ll be a big player for us, Daniel, and he’s got Championship quality.
Keeping it tight at the back was another of our superpowers last season, and I didn’t think we did badly on Saturday, but they could have been 2-0 up at one point. We bossed the second half, up to their goal, they’d had two chances with an xG of 0.01. Honestly, we were the better team in the second half; we created more and slightly better, but we didn’t have the technique and quality. It feels that simple.

The frustrating thing is that every game now comes with its own story. At Millwall we were 2-0 up and Hackett and Jefferies should have scored, and instead we drew 2-2, while Watford we should have taken a point from, and you could argue that if Birmingham had been sent off we’d have taken one there too. Those are all mitigating factors, but every time the outcome is the same, which is zero points. I get accused of being rose-tinted, and I do think we’ve produced competitive performances and that our numbers are strong, so I want to keep the faith. We’re still playing teams in the Championship that are far better funded than us, and eventually even that argument fades a little, because you look at it and go, we’re doing the right things, so where are the points?
That leads to my biggest concern, which goes beyond Saturday. We’re into November, deep into it, looking at December, and it all feels a little bit muddled, with no plan or identity that’s inherently Lincoln City. I think preparing for each game is good, but you can’t prepare entirely for the opposition every single week, because the second you get outmanoeuvred, as we did at QPR, everything you’ve planned goes out the window. You have to have a direction, a focus and a method of your own, and I fear that for whatever reason the changes were made, Saturday might be the first game where quite a few people are genuinely wondering what we are. Our work rate is good, our fight is good, our application is good, and our desire is good, but we lack quality in key areas. We do have players in and around the squad who you’d hope will add quality, and January is coming up, when we have to add quality in the top third, but where will they be deployed, and what is our pattern? We can’t just be the team that sets up to stop anyone else playing or to hold off somebody else’s threat.
People will tell me the step-up in quality is marked, but I’d argue that, actually, you don’t fight quality with quality. At one end you have opponents trying to score (quality) against defenders trying to stop them (organisation and application), and we’re good at that. Up the other end, you need quality to break the opponents’ organisation, and we’ve seen over 16 games; we lack it. Our xG, meaning the value of our chances, is good. With composure and better technique, we’d be comfortable in mid-table.

I wouldn’t be worrying about these individual moments and results if I thought there was some degree of progress, or some sense of solution. One mistake undid us Saturday, as otherwise I’m talking about a draw, and one decision undid Watford, as otherwise I’m talking about a draw there as well. We should be two points better off than we are, but I’m concerned that the progress isn’t there, that we’ve tried the different formations and personnel and we just don’t have the quality. Right now, it doesn’t feel like we’re the same team we were in August, putting teams under pressure from long throws and corners, winning the physical battles. Maybe I’m being harsh, because a lot of this was written last night, and I’ll come back in the morning with fresh eyes and maybe watch the highlights, so I may temper it a little (spoiler alert I didn’t).
If you want the quick assessment, actually, we were depleted; we tried a different lineup, it was no better or worse than the others, but because we lost, it’ll be blamed, when actually the shortcomings are ones we’ve been talking about all season, and they’re just beginning to become more exposed. Bet you wish you’d scrolled to that, rather than sit through the last 2,700 words, right?
Maybe reading this piece has felt like a hard slot. Right now, it does feel like there’s a similar, long, cold journey ahead, and I’m not sure we’re 100% on the route we’re going to take to navigate it.
Leave a Reply