Recruitment Podcast Summary: Six Players Our Imps Fans Think Would Work At Sincil Bank

Jamie McDonnell


If there’s one area we know we’ll need to address, it’s defensive midfield β€” assuming Ethan Erhahon departs. Jamie McDonnell, 21, spent 2024/25 on loan at Colchester United from Nottingham Forest and has the potential to be the perfect successor.

Across League Two, McDonnell ranked top among U23s for defensive duels and interceptions, and also placed second for aerial duels β€” a notable improvement on Erhahon. More impressively, his passing metrics were also strong, showing composure and distribution under pressure. Danny Cowley called him β€œChampionship ready.” That’s good enough for us.

Forest may want to loan him again, but if there’s any chance of a permanent deal, we should be at the front of the queue. Our long-standing relationship with Forest β€” Bridcutt, Johnson, Grant, Walker β€” could be a factor. McDonnell ticks every box: age, profile, upside, and availability. He’s the standout pick among all six.