6 – Johnson Clarke-Harris, 10 appearances, 6 goals
Jonson Clarke-Harris broke through at Coventry City, making senior history there in 2010 before leaving without a league appearance and starting again via Peterborough United, Southend United and Bury. Oldham Athletic gave him regular football from 2013 to 2014, then Rotherham United took him into the Championship from 2014 to 2018, with loan spells at Milton Keynes Dons, Doncaster Rovers and Coventry along the way. He later rebuilt his reputation at Coventry, Bristol Rovers and Peterborough, returned to Rotherham in 2024, and moved to Pendikspor in 2025.
He netted six in ten against us (he’s got seven in ten against Bradford City), but not a single one for Rotherham. Instead, he scored his goals for Posh, two in the infamous Szmodics 3-3 draw, two as they hammered us 4-0 and another in the same season as we went down 3-0 at home. He also bagged the winner in the first game after Danny and Nicky left against Bristol Rovers.